I would for sure buy it for a first timer...I just wanted a yote gun. Read a few good reviews on it.
Everything I have read on it has been positive. Like I said, I almost bought it as a pack gun and then I would have cut the barrel down to 16". I would have spent a couple hundred less than I spent.
I ended up with a Ruger M77 hawkeye compact in .308. The gun weighed 5.7 lbs and the barrel was already 16.5" long. I topped it with a Burris timberline and the whole thing loaded is less than 7lbs and 35" long. I have carried it on every shed hunting hike this year hoping to see a cat, yote or pig. I am happy with the gun, but, I may have been happy with the American also and saved a few hundred.
BTW, I see your "be the decoy" on Camofire and on some hunting shows. Congrats on getting that off the ground. You were a good sport when everyone was giving you crap about it. Hope it turns into some $ for you.